Acceptance Decision and Reviews of Submission 140 for MVA2011 (April 10, 2011) Acceptance Decision and Reviews of Submission 140 for MVA2011 Submission number 140 Authors or proposers Zhenyu Ye*, Yifan He, Roel Pieters, Bart Mesman, Henk Corporaal, Pieter Jonker Title Bottlenecks and Tradeoffs in High Frame Rate Visual Servoing: A Case Study Scroll down to view the publication decision and reviews when and if available Publication Decision for this Submission Timestamp February 25, 2011 00:24:11 Decision Accepted as Contributed paper, Poster Cover message Dear Dr. Ye, Thank you for your paper submission to The 12th IAPR Conference on Machine Vision Applications (MVA2011). We are pleased to inform you of the following review result. Your Paper: Submission number: 140 Title Bottlenecks and Tradeo ffs in Ultra High Frame Rate Visual Servoing: A Case Study Authors: Zhenyu Ye*, Yifan He, Roel Pieters, Bart Mesman, Henk Corporaal, Pieter Jonker has been accepted (for Poster presentation) at the conference and for publication in the proceedings. Please find enclosed reviewers' comments, which you are requested to address when you prepare the final camera-ready version of your paper. The standard length for the final paper is 4 pages, including all figures, references, appendices, etc. Up to two additional pages will be allowed for a fee of 10,000 yen per page, charged at the time of the registration. The paper should be printable on an A4 paper. The website, http://www.mva-org.jp/mva2011/, gives you the detailed information for authors, and you are requested to read the instruction carefully and follow it closely. Please note that the camera-ready manuscript should be received no later than March 25, 2011. Please note that at least one of the authors must register for the conference paying regular registration fees (not student fee) before submitting the camera-ready copy of his/her manuscript(s). Papers submitted without registration will not be included either in the conference program or in the proceedings. According to IAPR's policy, should an author have more than one paper accepted, only one registration is required for publication, although other authors are encouraged to register and participate in the conference. The deadline for Early Bird Registration is April 20, 2011. Each paper (oral or poster) must be presented by one of the authors in person at the conference. MVA reserves the right to cancel the acceptance of a paper and exclude the paper from distribution after the conference (e.g., removal from electronic archive of past MVA proceedings) if the paper is not presented at the conference. Please visit the conference web page (http://www.mva-org.jp/mva2011/) frequently for information on the Conference Program, Registration, and Hotel accommodation. If you have any questions about the conference and the proceedings, please contact us at the following e-mail address: mva2011-cms@m.aist.go.jp We are looking forward to seeing you at MVA2011 in Nara (June 13-15, 2011). Sincerely, Yasuyo KITA Program Chair, MVA2011 Comments to the author Reviews of this Submission Reviewer number Review ID Comments to the author Attachment to the review 1 2404 Very nice paper forward updated version to' MVA journal 2 2707 You should clarify what is new ideas in your proposal. 3 2708 This paper describes a design case of a high-speed visual servoing system. The reviewer thinks that the points readers may be interested in would be mainly in Section 4 and Section 5. However, descriptions in those sections are too specific to the authors' system and no useful knowledge could be found in this paper. The bottleneck analysis described in Section 4 is a commonly-used generic method to assess system performances. No novel method cannot be found in this section. The design methodology by exploring trade-offs between some performance metrics in the systems would be a useful approach, however, the authors only show the results of two specific implementations in their system (Figure 7) and the reviewer do not understand how the trade-offs have been explored to find the better configurations (what is the proposed methodology?) and how the methodology can be applied in other systems (what is the obtained knowledge in system design?).